While Castiel is yelling at Derek and Dean, Noah sneaks over to investigate the fallen pie. It's lying face down on the porch. He crouches next to it and carefully lifts the tin, revealing a perfectly safe and clean bottom, at least.

"You could probably still eat this," he says, and pokes at the pie crust. He breaks off a small piece and throws it at Derek, hoping he'll catch it in his mouth. "Catch!"